Sunday, May 27, 2012

Daring to do it: Challah!

The post this long is going to be a bit long.  But it is also very special.  This month I was the host of the Daring Baker's challenge.  This was so much fun.  I loved learning along with all of my fellow Bakers, and seeing everyone play with challah!  Huge thanks to Lis for giving me this chance, and endless love and thanks to the Bakers who played along!
And now for the long version of what I had to say about challah....

In almost all cultures, tradition and food go hand in hand.  Growing up in a traditionally Jewish household, holidays and celebrations are always centered around the table.  One of the most identifiable foods at the Jewish celebration table is the beautiful, braided bread – challah!  Even though we had challah every week, it was something we actually didn’t bake ourselves.  Our mom said it was the one type of bread that never turned out for her, so I just kind of assumed it would be too hard.  As a “grown up,” though, I decided to give it a chance, and discovered that it was a lot of fun, and a great way to make my own Sabbath tradition.

Believe it or not, the word “challah” does not actually mean bread.  Any whole loaves can be used at the Sabbath or holiday table for the traditional blessing.  Challah, instead, is the word referring to the portion of bread which, in the days of the Jewish temple in Jerusalem, was set aside and given to the high priests.  These days the challah portion is taken before the bread is baked, and is ritually burned as an offering.  There are specific guidelines concerning when the mitzvah (commandment) of challah is required – it has to do with how much flour is used.  The recipes I have provided are small enough that the challah portion would not need to be taken.  (I have actually never done this ritual – though I think I have made challah recipes which were big enough that, technically, I should have…  It is a learning process at all stages!)

A brief historical introduction:
Challah is a bread of celebration in Jewish tradition.  At a time when white flour was considered a luxury, its use was reserved for either the wealthy or for festive events.  In Judaism, the Sabbath is a weekly holiday, and therefore is a festive occasion.  It was around the 15th century when Jews in parts of Austria and Germany adopted an oval braided loaf from their neighbors to make the Sabbath special.  These fancy shaped loaves made with white flour were seen as a fitting way to honor the Shabbat (Sabbath), symbolized in Jewish culture as a queen, therefore deserving of the finest one can achieve.  In honoring the Sabbath as a day of rest, two loaves are traditionally put on the table.  This is generally seen as a representation of the double portion of manna provided to the Children of Israel on Fridays during their wandering in the desert after fleeing from Egypt.  This double portion allowed them to maintain the commandment to not do “work” on the Sabbath. 

Another symbolic comparison to the manna eaten by the Israelites is the fact that challah is traditionally covered with a cloth prior to being blessed and eaten.  According to tradition, manna was encased in dew to preserve its freshness. Covering the challah with a decorative cloth serves as another reminder of the special quality of the day of rest.  There are other explanations given regarding why the challah is covered.  The one which I always liked was that we cover the loaves so they will not be “embarrassed” by having to wait while the wine is blessed first.  (A traditional Sabbath dinner begins with a blessing over the wine first, followed by the blessing of the bread, after which the meal is enjoyed.)

Recipe Source:  The recipes provided for the challenge came from or were inspired by recipes found through a variety of online sources (including, but not limited to  Also invaluable was the book “A Taste of Challah,” by Tamar Ansh.

Blog-checking lines:  May’s Daring Bakers’ Challenge was pretty twisted – Ruth from The Crafts of Mommyhood challenged us to make challah!  Using recipes from all over, and tips from “A Taste of Challah,” by Tamar Ansh, she encouraged us to bake beautifully braided breads.

Posting Date:  May 27, 2012

Notes:  What makes challah truly stand out is the distinctive braid.  There are many ways, though, in which challah can be shaped.  While the recipes are important to this type of bread, it really is the shaping which makes it special.  Braiding is an intertwining of separate pieces into one combined entity.  This is symbolic of the intertwining of the everyday and the holy, and of the coming together of family and friends.  Some notes about the most common braids and shapes:

Three strand braid:  This is the easiest of the braids – especially if you have ever braided hair.  Many attribute a word to each of the three strands used: zachor (remember), shamor (observe or guard), and b’dibur echad (with one word).  The braiding of the three words is a physical reminder of the importance of remembering and observing the Sabbath as one commandment.
pics thru 4-4-2012

Four strand braid:  There is not a lot of information written as to the cultural significance of the four strands.  Rather, it is viewed as a way to elaborate on the more common three strand braid in order to fulfill the obligation to beautify the commandment and make it more special.

015challah 024

Six strand braid: There are traditionally two challah loaves on the Sabbath table.  Using the six strand braid, that brings twelve pieces to the table.  These twelve strands can be symbolic of the twelve tribes of the Children of Israel.  Many also use the twelve pieces to represent the twelve “showbreads” used in the Jewish Temple on special occasions.

pics thru 4-4-2012

Four strand braided round:  Traditionally used on the Jewish New Year, round breads have no beginning and no end. They are used as an example of the cycle of life, the cycle of the year, and the continuity of the Jewish calendar.

pics thru 4-4-2012

Other common shapes: Challah is shaped in a variety of ways for different Jewish holidays.  Prior to fasting on Yom Kippur, the Day of Attonement, many people eat loaves shaped like ladders to symbolize the desire to rise up to greater heights.  On Shavuot, the holiday commemorating receiving the ten commandments, loaves can be shaped like tablets.  Bird shaped challah loaves are symbols of protection and forgiveness.


Making strands: There are two basic methods for forming the strands used to braid challah.  The first, and easiest, is to simply roll snakes between your hands like when working with clay or play dough.  The second method is to use a rolling pin to roll out a flat disc of dough, then using your hands to roll the disc into a snake, rolling the snake on the counter with your fingers to achieve the length you need.  This second method does result in a better rise, but either way works well.  Whichever method you use, form your strands such that they are thinner at the ends and fuller in the middle.  This will help your challah rise in the center.


Tip: If you are new to braiding – do yourself a favor and practice before you shape your dough!  Over working the dough will make for a tough loaf.  Practice your braiding or shaping with clay or play dough first in order to become more comfortable.  Videos of how to do a variety of braids can be found in the additional information section.

Egg Wash:  Egg wash is used to enhance the top crust of the challah.  It adds shine and crispness, and enhances the beauty of the breads.  While a single coat is sufficient, a double coat works beautifully.  Brush your beaten egg and water mixture on the loaves directly after shaping, then allow to proof. Brush again just before baking, adding any toppings you were planning to use.


Mandatory Items: You must make an enriched bread which is braided or shaped.  If you must use a loaf pan, the bread should be braided before it goes into the pan.  Videos of several braiding methods are in the additional information section, and other tutorials are available on-line.  (The videos were done with four wonderful children – mine and my sister’s- playing in the background, sorry if they were distracting!)

Variations allowed: Challah comes in many different shapes, sizes and flavors.  Raisins, chocolate chips and other additions can be kneaded into the dough, loaves can be topped with poppy seeds, sesame seeds, vanilla sugar or other flavorful sprinklings, and filled challahs can be a lot of fun and very tasty, too!  Braiding and shaping, though, become more difficult when the rolled strands have fillings in them.  Use your own discretion and comfort level to determine what degree of difficulty you are ready for.  Gluten free and egg free bakers can use the recipe links in the additional information section, or use other substitutions with which you are comfortable.  (All of the recipes provided here are dairy free, as Jewish dietary laws prohibit eating dairy and meat at the same meal.  If you prefer not to use margarine, unsalted butter can be substituted.)

Preparation time:  As a general rule, challah takes about 4-6 hours from start to finish.  This includes making the dough, at least two risings, baking and cooling.  Specific recipes take slightly different amounts of time, and the first rise can be done overnight in the refrigerator if you prefer.  Please read through the recipes for specific times.  Following are approximates for most.
Mixing and kneading the dough: 20 min.
First rise: 1 ½ to 2 hours
Punching down, second rise: 1 hour (not all recipes have this second rise)
Shaping: 10 to 20 min.
Third rise (second rise for some recipes): 1 hour
Baking: 30 to 45 minutes
Cooling: 20 to 30 minutes.

Equipment required:
  • Stand mixer with dough hook (not necessary, but it certainly helps!)
  • Measuring cups
  • Measuring spoons
  • Mixing bowls (at least one large and one small)
  • Pastry brush
  • Rolling pin (again, not necessary, but it makes a difference)
  • Baking tray/cookie sheet
  • Parchment paper
  • Kitchen/tea towel
  • Cooling rack
  • Offset spatula (really helps get the loaves off of the tray safely!)

Ruth’s “Go-To” Whole Wheat Challah
(adapted from D’s Whole Wheat Challah)
Servings: 12

2 (.25 oz.) packages (4½ teaspoons) (22½ ml) (15 gm) (½ oz) dry yeast
1 cup (240 ml) warm water (100°F/38°C)
½ cup (120 ml) (100 gm) (3½ oz) brown sugar, firmly packed
½ cup (one stick) (120 ml) (115 gm/4 oz) margarine or unsalted butter – room temperature
2 tsp. (10 ml) (15 gm) (½ oz) salt
3 large eggs
2 cups (480 ml) (280 gm/10 oz) whole wheat flour
2 cups (480 ml) (280 gm/10 oz) all-purpose flour
½ cup (120 ml) (50 gm) (1¾ oz) rolled oats (Old Fashioned work just fine!)
Additional flour for kneading (½ to 1 cup) (120 to 240 ml) (70 to 140 gm) (2½ to 5 oz)
1 egg beaten with 1 tsp. water for glaze


1.      In the bowl of your stand mixer, dissolve yeast in warm water.  Allow to stand about 5 minutes until creamy/foamy.
2.      With paddle attachment beat 3 eggs, sugar, margarine (or butter), whole wheat flour, all purpose flour and oats into the yeast mixture.  Or, if mixing by hand (ok, spoon), combine eggs and margarine/butter with yeast mixture until well mixed.  Add flours and oats and mix until it becomes difficult to mix.
3.      Once combined, switch to the dough hook and knead for 5 to 10 minutes until smooth and elastic, adding flour as/if needed.  If kneading by hand, this should take about 10-12 minutes.
4.      Form dough into a round, compact ball.  Turn in oiled bowl, cover with a kitchen/tea towel.  Let rise in warm area (I put it in the oven with the light on) until doubled, approx. 2 hours.
5.      Once dough has doubled, punch down.  Recover with towel, allow to rise again for an hour, but even 30 minutes will be fine if you’re in a hurry. 
6.      Punch the dough down again, divide in two.
7.      Shape each half as desired (3, 4 or 6 strand braid, rolls, etc.).  Place shaped loaves onto parchment covered baking trays.  Cover with the towel and allow to rise another hour.
8.      Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
9.      Brush loaves with egg wash.  (Sprinkle with vanilla sugar/sesame seeds/poppy seeds/other topping here if desired)
10.  Bake 30 to 40 min. until the loaf sounds hollow when tapped on the bottom.
11.     Transfer loaves to a wire rack to cool before serving.

Challah (Honey White)
Servings: 2 loaves

1 ½ cups (360 ml) warm water, separated
1 Tbsp. (15 ml) (15 gm/½ oz sugar
2 Tbsp. (2-2/3 packets) (30 ml) (18 gm) (2/3 oz) dry active yeast
½ cup (120 ml) honey
1 Tbsp. (15 ml) oil (light colored vegetable oil, or olive oil if you prefer)
4 large eggs
1 ½ tsp. 7½ ml) (9 gm) (1/3 oz) salt
5 cups (1200 ml) (700 gm/25 oz) all-purpose (plain) flour, plus more as needed (up to 8 or 9 cups total)
1 egg beaten with 1 tsp. water


  1. In mixer bowl/large mixing bowl combine ½ cup warm water, 1 Tbsp. sugar and 2 Tbsp. yeast.  Allow to proof approximately 5 minutes until foamy.
  2. To the yeast mixture add the remaining water, honey, oil, eggs, salt and 5 cups of flour. Knead (by hand or with your mixer’s dough hook) until smooth, adding flour as needed.  Knead for approximately 10 minutes.
  3. Transfer dough to a clean, oiled bowl, turn to coat or add a bit more oil on top.  Cover bowl with a kitchen/tea towel.  Leave to rise in a warm place until doubled, about 1 ½ hours. 
  4. Punch down the dough, divide it into two sections.  Use one half to make each loaf (shaped or braided as desired).
  5. Place loaves on parchment lined or greased baking sheets, cover with a towel, allow to rise 30 minutes.
  6. Preheat oven to 325 degrees.
  7. Brush tops loaves with egg wash.  (Sprinkle with seeds or toppings here if wanted.)
  8. Bake loaves 30-40 minutes until done.
  9. Cool on wire racks.

Easy Challah

4 cups (960 ml) (360 gm/20 oz) all-purpose (plain) flour
1 cup (240 ml) warm water
1 package (2¼ teaspoons) (11¼ ml) (7 gm) (¼ oz) package rapid rise yeast
½ (120 ml) (115 gm/4 oz) cup sugar
2 large eggs
1 tsp. (5 ml) (6 gm) salt
1 egg beaten with 1 tsp. water


1.      Measure flour, sugar and salt into a large mixing bowl.
2.      In a separate bowl (or in the bowl of your stand mixer) combine water and yeast, allow to sit 5 minutes until foamy.
3.      Add 1 ½ cups of the flour mixture to the water and yeast mixture, beat until well combined.  Cover with a dish towel, let stand 30 min.
4.      Add two eggs to the dough, beat again.
5.      By hand or with your dough hook knead in the remaining flour mixture.  Knead approximately 10 minutes.
6.      Transfer to oiled bowl, cover, let rise one hour.
7.      Punch down dough, knead approximately 3 minutes.
8.      Divide dough in two.  Shape each half as desired (3, 4, or 6 strand braid).
9.      Place loaves on parchment covered or greased cookie sheets, cover with a towel, allow to rise one hour.
10.  Preheat oven to 400 degrees.
11.  Brush loaves with egg wash.
12.  Bake at 400 degrees for 10 minutes.  Reduce oven temperature to 375 degrees, bake until golden crust forms (about 25-30 minutes).
13.  Transfer to a wire rack to cool.

Storage & Freezing Instructions/Tips:

Once cooled, challah loaves which will not be eaten right away (or in the next couple of days) should be bagged in heavy duty freezer bags.  Remove excess air from the bag before securing it tightly (tying a knot or using tape).  Put the bagged loaf/loaves into the freezer as soon as possible to ensure fresh taste; frozen challah will keep approximately three months.

Additional Information: 
Egg free recipes: This recipe uses baking powder for the egg-replacer.  The resulting loaves were light and fluffy, and tasted better than I thought they would!
This recipe uses a more common egg replacer – flax seed meal.  It was a tougher dough than I was used to using, but the resulting loaves were light, and looked beautiful with the flax speckles.
Videos:  These videos were made in my kitchen.  The kids – mine and my sister’s were running around.  So it is totally a real world view, no fancy tricks happening!
Additional resources:

Just a quick thank you to my sister Shelley, C Mom Cook, for your help in photographing, videoing, and editing this challenge.  I appreciate your input and that of your kiddos, too!


  1. This was an excellent DB challenge. Thank you Ruth! And for all the information you've given about challah. Your "go-to" recipe is now mine too! The rolled oats were such a nice addition.
    Also, I thought it was awesome that you replied to practically every comment and post in the DB forum. You really put a lot of time and effort into hosting this challenge, so thank you once again!

  2. Thanks so much, Ruth - it was a wonderful challenge and were a brilliant host :)

  3. Thanks so much, Ruth! I loved learning to braid! You explained everything so well. The Honey White recipe is fantastic! Thanks for being a great host!

  4. Thank you Ruth for this challenge, I really enjoyed it and the "go-to" recipe is gonna be a classic in my kitchen.

  5. Thank you for a great challenge! :) Loved it!
    Pozdrawiam, Anula.

  6. Awesome job, awesome challenge, and awesome challot! :) You should be super proud of this one. :)

  7. Loved the challenge Ruth, thank you!:)

  8. Thanks Ruth - it was such a great challenge! loved it!

  9. Ruth - you did an amazing job putting this one together. I love the challah variations you presented!

  10. Ruth, thank you! It's obvious you put so much work into this challenge with all of the information and the videos. I love that I learned something totally new!

  11. Wonderful challenge, Ruth. Thanks so much! I've always admired challah from afar, and I'm so pleased I got to make it myself. Your videos were really helpful & the end result tasted amazing. I'll be trying your go-to wheat challah next. Thanks again!

  12. Ruth, thank you for this wonderful challenge!!! I have really loved getting to know challah better this month, and I really love this bread!! You did an awesome job hosting this month's challenge!!! :)

  13. Thank for sucha fun challenge. I made it three times in the past week! you were a great host!!!

  14. This challah is one of our new favorites! Thank you for hosting such a fun and delicious challenge. I am looking forward to making this bread again and again!

  15. I enjoyed this challenge tremedously - thanks Ruth! I especially loved reading all about the origins of challah and the various braids. Wishing you a peaceful Shavuot.

  16. Thanx Ruth for a wonderful challenge and for introducing us to this braided beauties.
    You really are an awesome host for you were there whole month answering/commenting/guiding each new entry or comment on the daring kitchen.
    Once again thank you, we really had a great time.
    Have a nice day!

  17. This was such a neat challenge! Gorgeous photos to show to do it (very helpful!) And that's sweet that your sis was able to help you out. Makes it double the fun :)

  18. Ruth, Thank you for such a great challenge and you are a wonderful host. Loved the videos so much. Like I said in the forums, you are one of the fastest braiders I've ever seen! I only wish the humidity didn't kill my braiding :( I can't wait to try the 4-strand round loaf once the humidity breaks!

  19. Thanks so much for presenting us with this awesome challenge! I'd never made challah before and your "go-to" recipes were really easy to play with. I will definitely keep these in my recipe book!

  20. Even though it refused to work for me, I WILL be trying this again sometime, cause I love Challah bread.}:P

  21. Thxs for hosting this month challenge on daring bakers!! absolutely loved it

  22. Thanks so much Ruth for the great challenge. I have so many wonderful memories of challah on the table. It came out beautiful and delicious!

  23. thanks so much for a great challenge Ruth....i loved the Challah. It was a perfect recipe:)


  24. Thanks for hosting this challenge Ruth :) So much fun and so many beautiful challot! :)

  25. thanks for hosting, i really enjoyed this one!

    you might want to change the color of your headings, as you can't read the recipe titles w/the background on your blog :(

  26. Ruth, thank you so much for this month's challenge. I learned a lot, and not just about baking. I really enjoyed it and look forward to making more challah in the future, in all kinds of shapes and sizes. I've linked up your post now so that anyone who reads my post can come over here and see how it's really done! x

  27. I had a question about wheat challah ... What wheat flour do I use ? The first time I tried it it was so hard

  28. Thank you, Ruth, for this amazing challenge and thorough instructions. (And the etymology of the word 'challah' - always wondered why we had 'lechem' too) I also can't believe how good it came out. Your video instructions on the braiding were truly excellent. :)

  29. Great job hosting, Ruth! This was such a great challenge, as I've really been meaning to make Challah. And I'm so glad I did because it was WAY easier than I remembered! Mine didn't turn out quite as beatiful as your loaves though...yours are so perfect!!!

  30. Thanks for a great challenge, Ruth! I really enjoyed it and your braiding video was really helpful. I know there are more 4-strand round loaves in my future....

  31. Thank you for such an amazing challenge this month, Ruth! With your instruction and wonderful guidance, I had bread success where I have failed so many times before.

  32. Thanks for the challenge and the new whole wheat challah recipe!

  33. Thanks so much Ruth! We had a great time with the Challah. Your loaves are lovely!

  34. Thanks for such a fun (and informative) challenge! The videos were so incredibly helpful! I really loved braiding the dough and the whole wheat recipe turned out to be so delicious.

  35. Thank you for this challenge Ruth! I just posted today, super late but I didn't want to miss it :)

  36. Thank you so much for this challenge Ruth, it was loads of fun and I learnt alot
    you put so much effort into the challenge and it really shows..thank you

  37. I didn't want to miss the oportunity to thank you for the great challenge you prepared for us, getting to know this bread was so fun and delicious.
    I also had the chance to take a look at your blog and think I came here to stay!!
    Thanks again.

  38. This is a recipe that does not include eggs in the dough itself and include baking tips:


  39. Really had a super great time doong this challenge. You did such an excellent job and the videos were quite helpful. Thanksa again and have a great day